The Journal of Integrated Enterprise Systems

Review Form for Paper

Paper ID  

Paper Title  

Reviewer ID  

Reviewer Password  


1. Relevance of the Topic to Enterprise Systems (ERP or CRM) or Relalated Systems (Business Intelligence, etc.)


Relevant      5       4       3       2       1      Not Relevant           Not Applicable

2. Readability of the Paper

Excellent      5       4       3       2       1      Poor                    Not Applicable

3. Relevance of References

Excellent      5       4       3       2       1      Poor                     Not Applicable

4. Contribution to Teaching and Curriculum

Relevant      5       4       3       2       1      Not Relevant           Not Applicable

5. Contribution to Field of Knowledge

Relevant      5       4       3       2       1      Not Relevant           Not Applicable

6. Quality of Research Method

Excellent      5       4       3       2       1      Poor                     Not Applicable

7. Overall Evaluation

Accept      5       4       3       2       1     Reject

8

When you have completed filling out the above form, please click on the Submit button below. If you are not satisfied with your answers above please click on Cancel to clear the form.

   
If you have problem to use this form, please e-mail your review to:

Huei Lee, Ph.D.
Professor of CIS
Department of CIS
Eastern Michigan University
Ypsilanti, MI 48187
Tel: (734)487-4044
E-Mail: huei.lee@emich.edu